Two men tied to construction companies now face federal prison after a federal jury in Florida found they used a service-disabled veteran's company as a front to win an $8.9 million VA cancer center contract that ended with the half-built facility torn down. The Justice Department announced the verdict on Nov. 17, 2026 as a featured case in its first coordinated national surge against veterans benefits fraud, run by the National Fraud Enforcement Division with the VA and the VA Office of Inspector General. For contractors who team with service-disabled veteran-owned small businesses (SDVOSBs), the case is a reminder that prosecutors look past the name on the award to who actually runs the job and collects the money.
Matthew West and Kevin Kutina were convicted of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and major fraud against the United States in U.S. v. Matthew West and Kevin Kutina (8:23-cr-308-WFJ-AEP) in the Middle District of Florida. Co-defendants Robert and William Gonzalez pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud. The sources did not state sentencing dates.
How the $8.9 Million Bay Pines Set-Aside Was Won
In 2016, the VA solicited bids to build the Cancer Infusion Therapy Center at Bay Pines VA Medical Center in Florida, and reserved the $8.9 million contract for SDVOSBs. According to the Justice Department, "Evidence at trial established that Matthew West, Kevin Kutina, and their co-conspirators secured the contract through false statements and material omissions regarding who would perform and manage the work."
The award went to a company that did qualify. The problem was the paperwork behind it. Undisclosed agreements, the department said, showed that non-qualifying entities would perform most of the work and receive the majority of the contract payments. After winning the job, the conspirators kept concealing the arrangement through further false statements and omissions to the VA.
The 2023 indictment, announced by the U.S. Attorney's Office in Tampa on Oct. 4, 2023, laid out the structure in more detail. The SDVOSB of record was Maxon Groupe LLC, owned and operated by service-disabled veteran Roberto Gonzalez (as the indictment spelled his name) and William Gonzalez. Prosecutors alleged that Maxon was a pass-through for West Construction Inc., which managed nearly all the work and received most of the payment. "West Construction, Inc. was not a company eligible for the SDVOSB set-aside contract," the indictment announcement stated. "As a result of the false statements and omissions within the bid proposal, the VA awarded the contract to Maxon."
Kutina's company, Kevcon Inc., played a different role in the bid. The conspirators allegedly represented that qualified Kevcon employees would fill supervisory positions under a teaming agreement between Maxon and Kevcon, a representation prosecutors called false.
Where the $4.8 Million in Treasury Payments Went
Between March 2017 and January 2019, the conspirators submitted multiple invoices, and the U.S. Treasury paid Maxon approximately $4.8 million, according to the indictment announcement. Over the same period, prosecutors alleged, about $4.2 million of those funds moved to West, and West in turn sent about $1.1 million to Kevcon. The government sought forfeiture of at least $4,835,035, which it described as the proceeds of the criminal conduct.
The VA got no usable building for the money. The Justice Department said that "The project was plagued by construction failures, resulting in the partially completed Cancer Infusion Therapy Center being demolished and never rebuilt."
At indictment, prosecutors said the defendants faced a maximum of 20 years in federal prison on each conspiracy and wire fraud count and up to 10 years on the major fraud count. The verdict announcement names Assistant U.S. Attorneys Tiffany Fields and Samantha Newman as prosecuting the case.
What the First National VA Fraud Surge Produced
The Bay Pines verdict was one of eight sample cases DOJ highlighted from the surge. Between Sept. 1 and Nov. 17, 2026, the Fraud Division and 17 U.S. Attorneys' Offices brought charges against 15 defendants whose alleged and proven crimes intended an estimated loss to the government of more than $3.4 million. The department also counted sentencings, pleas and trial verdicts totaling more than $19 million in intended loss over the same window.
"Veterans and their families deserve protection from anyone seeking to exploit their service or steal the benefits they earned," said VA Inspector General Cheryl Mason.
Most of the featured cases involve stolen benefit payments, but one more touches VA purchasing directly. In U.S. v. Yolanda Johnson Sayed (Southern District of Texas), a prosthetics representative at the Houston VA Medical Center was charged by criminal information with conspiracy to commit wire fraud. According to the charging document, she conspired with the owner of a VA-approved vendor to steer purchase orders to the company and approve inflated delivery charges on mobility equipment such as wheelchairs and walkers, paying the invoices with government-issued purchase cards. Prosecutors allege about 1,437 transactions with the vendor between November 2020 and August 2025 and roughly $182,000 in losses. Those charges are allegations, and she is presumed innocent.
The department paired the surge with a new Texas Federal Fraud Task Force made up of all four U.S. Attorney's Offices in Texas. "When you defraud the VA, you defraud veterans who are owed benefits and you defraud the taxpayer for providing them," said U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz of the Southern District of Texas.
What It Means for Contractors
The Bay Pines case turned on three facts prosecutors could prove from documents: who was named in the bid, who actually managed the work, and where the payments went. Each one is a record that a contracting officer, an inspector general or a jury can reconstruct years later.
- Teaming agreements are representations. Kevcon's promised supervisors were part of the bid. If a teaming partner's personnel are named in a proposal, those people need to actually do that work.
- Payment flows tell the story. Prosecutors traced roughly $4.2 million of $4.8 million from the SDVOSB awardee to an ineligible firm. Set-aside primes should be able to show that their share of the work and money matches what they told the agency.
- Undisclosed side agreements are the core risk. The award went to a genuinely eligible firm. The crime, as the jury found it, was hiding the arrangements that put ineligible companies in charge.
- Purchase-card vendors are in scope too. The Houston case shows prosecutors are also pursuing small-dollar, high-volume vendor relationships, not only construction awards.
With a dedicated Fraud Division now running coordinated surges and a statewide task force in Texas, SDVOSB primes and the firms that sub to them should expect more of this kind of review.
Sources
- Justice Department, VA, and VA OIG Announce Enforcement Actions Against 15 Defendants for Defrauding Veterans Benefits Programs (DOJ Office of Public Affairs, Nov. 17, 2026)
- Four Indicted for Defrauding Federal Program Intended for Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned Small Businesses (USAO Middle District of Florida, Oct. 4, 2023, via Wayback Machine)