The Pentagon is pouring money into munitions production without a department-wide plan that ties those buys to what the military actually needs, and no single office is in charge of fixing the shortfall, the Government Accountability Office says. That gap leaves the services and their suppliers chasing the most urgent shortage of the moment, according to GAO's report "DOD Munitions: Planning and Leadership Needed to Address Persistent Shortages" (GAO-27-109420), as described by Air & Space Forces Magazine and DefenseScoop. The watchdog released the unclassified version on Nov. 19, two months after a classified version, Air & Space Forces Magazine reported.

The Iran war has only amplified the problem, DefenseScoop reported the GAO report says. Its central message is that without an overarching plan, DOD "is not positioned to address these gaps" in low munitions inventories, and the department stays "reactive to global events," running the risk of pouring dollars into specific near-term requirements while overlooking shortages across the board.

Why the 155mm Shell Ramp-Up Became GAO's Cautionary Example

The Defense Department has not stood still. Air & Space Forces Magazine notes the report cites the Air Force's 2023 munitions roadmap, the National Defense Industrial Strategy from early 2024 and the Army's Ammunition Plant Modernization Plan of 2025, along with working groups created to focus on munitions, such as the Munitions Acceleration Council and the Joint Industrial Base Working Group. None of these, GAO concludes, adds up to a centralized plan that links munitions production and funding to total requirements and sets common goals and metrics.

The report's example is the Army's surge in 155 millimeter artillery shell production. DefenseScoop reported that the surge addressed service-specific shortages but was not driven by total munitions requirements, according to GAO.

GAO warns of the opposite risk too. Per Air & Space Forces Magazine, the report says that without an overarching munitions plan that links production and funding to total requirements and identifies long-term goals, strategies and metrics to gauge progress, "DOD and the services are not well-positioned to effectively address persistently low munitions inventories." Failure could mean "investing in munitions that are projected to exceed the total munition requirement," the authors wrote.

Diana Moldafsky, director of defense capabilities and management at GAO, told DefenseScoop the approach is piecemeal. "Everybody is operating in kind of a vacuum of the closest need that we need to deal with now without considering how that need matches up with all of our other requirements and industrial base needs," she said.

Who Owns the Munitions Problem at the Pentagon?

The second gap is leadership. GAO's unclassified report cites the lack of a high-level office empowered with the authority and responsibility to develop, manage and execute a comprehensive, department-wide munitions program. According to Air & Space Forces Magazine, the report notes that the offices overseeing industrial base and munitions policy lack the budget authorities to solve problems, and working groups such as the Munitions Acceleration Council lack decision-making authority.

The services want that kind of centralized oversight, GAO said. "Service officials stated that without an office with dedicated leadership to address munitions challenges, it may be difficult to realize progress in addressing munitions shortages at any level," the report says.

Advertisement

The Pentagon accepted the point. In its formal response, the department agreed it needs an overarching plan and should create an office to oversee it, indicating that the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment will take the lead. That office already leads the Munitions Acquisition Council, and David S. Cadman, acting principal deputy assistant secretary of defense for acquisition, signed the response, Air & Space Forces Magazine reported.

What GAO Found Inside the 37-Source Munitions Readiness Initiative

The third finding concerns the numbers senior leaders see. The services collect and maintain their own munitions inventories, and that data flows into the department-wide Munitions Readiness Initiative (MRI), a tool that pulls from 37 data sources and is designed to consolidate service-specific munitions metrics for senior leaders in real time, DefenseScoop reported. GAO found that DOD officials have "limited oversight over this tool," and the data is not regularly crosschecked or reconciled with the services' own databases. DefenseScoop also reported that MRI lacks a data management plan.

Moldafsky told DefenseScoop that the department has not "routinely had a formal process for going back and ensuring that the data is correct or up to date." She said the check-ins happen "on a really ad hoc basis," and that GAO found a few instances of discrepancies between the services and MRI. Air & Space Forces Magazine reported that officials from all four services said more regular reconciliations would help ensure the accuracy of what MRI displays.

Advertisement

Standardization is a related weakness. Each service collects its own data on munitions, and the department lacks a system to describe and standardize that data once it is consolidated, Air & Space Forces Magazine reported. "DOD is limited in its ability to monitor how data is aggregated or whether certain data quality standards are met, potentially affecting the accuracy of information in MRI," auditors concluded.

Three Fixes GAO Wants and Where DOD Pushed Back

GAO's recommendations track its three findings:

  • An overarching munitions plan, drawn up under the secretary of defense, with long-term goals, strategies and metrics to gauge progress.
  • One office given the authorities to oversee the munitions revival.
  • Regular reconciliation of inventory data between the services and the Office of the Under Secretary for Acquisition and Sustainment, plus standards to make munitions data consistent across services.

DOD mostly agreed, DefenseScoop reported. The exception was GAO's proposal that the Chief Digital and Artificial Intelligence Office, since renamed the Super Intelligence Office, oversee the data management plan. The department said that role belongs to Acquisition and Sustainment. GAO agreed, while adding that the Super Intelligence Office should have a hand in the plan.

Moldafsky said the reconciliation recommendation rests on the department's own data guidebooks. "So they recognize that they should be doing this," she said. On the larger plan, her warning was direct: "This is a very tough effort and it requires a lot of prioritization, so you need to have a strategy to guide a department-wide solution, or I think they’ll have a tough time actually accomplishing any of their goals and addressing any of the shortages that they currently have."

What It Means for Contractors

For munitions primes, energetics suppliers and component makers, the report points toward a possible shift from surge-by-surge buying toward demand tied to a total requirement. If Acquisition and Sustainment builds the plan GAO describes, companies could see clearer long-term goals to plan capacity against. Because GAO flags the risk of investing in munitions projected to exceed the total requirement, lines where projected buys outrun that requirement could draw closer attention.

A single accountable office would also give industry one place where production, funding and requirements meet. Firms weighing capital investment in new lines should watch how that office is chartered and whether it gets real budget authority, which GAO says today's offices and working groups lack.

Sources