Defense contractors that feared the Pentagon would demand far more of their internal cost data, and even tap their accounting systems directly, have gotten some relief, but not a reprieve. Three Defense Department memos issued in August, September and October pair a push to strip out government-unique accounting rules with a continued drive for deeper visibility into what suppliers charge, according to Haynes Boone partner Dan Ramish in a Federal News Network interview published Nov. 17. The October implementation memo from Defense Pricing, Contracting, and Acquisition Policy pulls back the most aggressive data demands, opens the door to commercially benchmarked profit, and leaves the biggest changes to future DFARS rulemaking.
Ramish described the three documents as pulling in opposite directions: the department’s “continuing concerns about obtaining data that’s sufficient to negotiate contracts with suppliers in a non-competitive environment,” set against a “major push to deregulate government contract cost and policy.”
What the August Cost Transparency Memo Asked For
The August supplier cost and pricing transparency memo used the strongest language of the three. Ramish said it described substantially expanded access to actual cost data on contract actions over $10 million, reaching commercial products and services companies and suppliers at all tiers, regardless of whether adequate price competition was achieved or other Truth in Negotiations Act exceptions applied. Only commercial-off-the-shelf items were excluded.
That would have been a real expansion. Contracting officers typically do not seek detailed cost data where competition sets the price or where a commercial item exception applies. The memo also told program managers and contracting officers to actively enforce cost and software data reporting requirements, which apply generally to contracts over $50 million or to certain high-risk contracts on major acquisition programs.
The provision that drew the most industry attention said the Under Secretary for Acquisition and Sustainment would explore an automated solution: application programming interfaces that pull cost information directly from contractors' enterprise resource planning or other financial systems. Ramish said simply, “So that got people’s attention.”
How the October Memo Walked Back API Access and Data Demands
The October implementation memo responded to that pushback. Ramish said it reinforced the established hierarchy in FAR Part 15 and the statute governing data other than certified cost or pricing data. That hierarchy directs contracting officers to use data already held by the government or available from other sources before asking an offeror for cost data to determine fair and reasonable prices.
The memo also addressed the ERP and API question. Any automated data integration, if pursued, would go through formal rulemaking, would be strictly voluntary, would not penalize contractors that decline, and would not be a condition of award. Ramish called the overall shift "some level of walk back" from the August language and summarized the practical effect: “the implementation memo provides protection for contractors to some extent from having to give up significantly more cost data than they’ve traditionally done, absent further rulemaking.”
Could Weighted Guidelines Give Way to Commercial Profit Benchmarks?
The October memo also signals a possible change in how the department sets profit. According to Ramish, DoD may move away from the long-standing DFARS weighted guidelines method toward commercially benchmarked profit margins. Contracting officers are directed to tailor profit models with sector-specific benchmarks that inform negotiation objectives but do not act as caps.
The memo sketches those benchmarks by sector:
- Hardware and weapon systems: aligned with commercial manufacturing risk-to-reward ratios, adjusted for self-funded facilities, nonrecurring engineering investment and execution risk, not merely cost incurred.
- Software and IT services: reflecting commercial software-as-a-service margins and R&D investment, scaled to the company's life cycle and the software's maturity.
- Services and sustainment: modeled on commercial logistics and third-party maintenance rates driven by performance-based metrics.
Ramish read the approach as an acknowledgment that contractors making significant investments or facing significant risk may warrant higher margins than the traditional cost-based model allows.
The September Memo's Plan to Make CAS Exemptions the Default
The September industrial-base memo carries the deregulatory side. Ramish said DoD plans to propose that the Cost Accounting Standards Board make CAS exemptions the default; confine coverage to sole-source, cost-based development or incentive-fee procurements; apply coverage only to covered contracts rather than an entire company or segment; finish the CAS-GAAP conformance effort; and replace disclosure statements with a short certification tied to the contractor's audited GAAP financial statements.
“These have all been efforts to reduce government unique requirements, recognizing that that drives up costs for the government and the taxpayer at the end of the day,” Ramish said, noting that commercial accounting under GAAP has evolved considerably since the standards were first written.
Senators Want Cost Data Below the $10 Million Line
Congress is pressing from the other side. In October, Sens. Elizabeth Warren, Joni Ernst, Chuck Grassley and Elissa Slotkin wrote Deputy Defense Secretary Steve Feinberg asking how the department will obtain cost and pricing data on contracts below $10 million and whether it will disqualify contractors that refuse to provide it. Last year, Congress raised the threshold for certified cost or pricing data from $2.5 million to $10 million.
“The Pentagon can implement the Aug. 18 directive in a way that limits the scope of these problems and ensures contracting officers have the necessary data to negotiate fair and reasonable prices,” the senators wrote, adding that reviews under the directive “should not be limited only to those contracts that exceed $10 million.”
Both the House and Senate versions of the fiscal 2027 defense policy bill include provisions requiring contractors to notify DoD of price increases within 30 days of becoming aware of rising costs, with the Defense Contract Audit Agency reporting contractors that fail to comply.
What It Means for Contractors
For now, the October memo lets companies lean on existing rules. Ramish advised contractors to scrutinize data requests, ask contracting officers for the basis of any request and why prices, market data and sales information are insufficient, and, when data must be provided, deliver it in the format already kept in their own systems.
Supply chains should expect more scrutiny. Primes should assess how much visibility they have into supplier costs, and lower-tier suppliers should prepare for direct requests that they can answer by reference to existing FAR standards. Contractors should also be ready to justify above-nominal year-over-year price increases, particularly on sole-source items, a point the implementation memo calls out.
The larger shifts on profit policy, data requirements and business systems will come through DFARS rulemaking and may be folded into the FAR overhaul. Ramish said industry comments in those proceedings can help keep cost data policy from undercutting the government's broader commercial buying reforms. With senators and both NDAA versions pushing for more pricing visibility, those comment periods are where contractors can shape how far the data demands reach.