The Department of Veterans Affairs has to reopen the competition for its upright marble headstone contract after the Government Accountability Office found that the agency gave the winning bidder one more round of discussions than the losing bidder got. In a decision dated Nov. 9, 2026, GAO sustained in part and denied in part a protest from American Veteran Contracting Solutions, LLC, a service-disabled veteran-owned small business (SDVOSB) in Mesa, Arizona. The award went to Veterans Monument Company, LLC, an SDVOSB in Caledonia, Mississippi, whose final offer was $42,995,000.

GAO rejected two of the protester's arguments, one aimed at the lowest-price evaluation scheme and one aimed at the awardee's quality control plan. It sustained the third. That ground decided the case: the VA National Cemetery Administration talked with the two finalists on unequal terms, and GAO would not assume the extra round made no difference.

What the VA Was Buying for National Cemeteries

The National Cemetery Administration issued request for proposals 36C78626R0015 on Jan. 23, 2026, and closed it on Feb. 23, 2026. According to the decision, the agency furnishes headstones, markers and monuments for deceased veterans worldwide, and this solicitation covered the manufacture, packaging and nationwide distribution of blank marble upright headstones under a firm-fixed-price, indefinite-quantity contract with a one-year base period and four one-year options. GAO's decision lists an independent government cost estimate (IGCE) of $43,992,500.

The RFP evaluated proposals in tiers, with SDVOSBs first, then veteran-owned small businesses, small businesses and large businesses. The agency received four responsive proposals, but only Veterans Monument and American Veteran competed in the SDVOSB tier.

How $4 Million Separated the Two Headstone Bids

According to the decision, Veterans Monument opened at $43,799,500, just under the government estimate. American Veteran's initial offer was $47,515,140. American Veteran later revised to $47,127,500 and then submitted a best and final offer of $47,031,425. Veterans Monument's best and final offer came in at $42,995,000.

GAO's account puts Veterans Monument's final price $997,500 below the IGCE and American Veteran's $3,038,925 above it. Under the RFP's evaluation scheme, that gap mattered a great deal. Within a tier, the agency could award to the lowest-priced proposal that was technically acceptable, without evaluating higher-priced proposals, and the VA found American Veteran's final price not fair and reasonable when compared to the IGCE.

Why GAO Upheld the Lowest-Price Technically Acceptable Scheme

American Veteran first challenged the award as an improper application of the solicitation's selection method. It argued that the VA wrongly treated the procurement as a lowest-priced, technically acceptable (LPTA) competition when the RFP called for a price-technical tradeoff, pointing to language about the "most advantageous" offer. GAO disagreed. The RFP stated that "[a]ward may be made to the lowest-priced proposal that is determined to be technically acceptable within that tier," and GAO found the VA's selection followed that plain language.

The protester also attacked Veterans Monument's quality control plan. According to the decision, the awardee's plan specifically identified the firm's owner as the person responsible for quality control, while two other individuals were tied to quality tasks elsewhere in the proposal. American Veteran argued that this was inconsistent. GAO observed that the RFP asked for the "individual(s) responsible for quality control" and did not require offerors to name every person involved in ensuring quality standards. It found the VA's technical evaluation reasonable and consistent with the solicitation and denied that ground.

Advertisement

The Extra Round of Discussions That Sank the Award

The sustained ground came down to how many chances each offeror got to improve its proposal. The VA opened discussions with both offerors on April 30, after earlier corrective action, raising workforce concerns with Veterans Monument and price concerns with American Veteran. The agency then held a follow-up round only with the awardee, asking for resumes and qualifications of the direct hires it had identified. GAO found that "the agency conducted one round of discussions with the protester and two rounds of discussions with the awardee."

GAO said discussions must be meaningful, equitable and not misleading, and that agencies may not engage in conduct that favors one offeror over another. It concluded that the agency gave the awardee a second chance to resolve issues with its technical proposal but did not advise the protester a second time about its price, which GAO called unfair.

Advertisement

The VA argued that American Veteran could not have been prejudiced because its price stayed far above the awardee's, a gap of roughly $4 million at the end. GAO did not accept that argument. The decision states that GAO will "resolve any doubts concerning the prejudicial effect of the agency's actions in favor of the protester." GAO said it could not eliminate the possibility that, told a second time that its price was still unreasonably high, American Veteran would have cut its price to match or beat the awardee's. The decision notes that American Veteran's total price reduction between its March 30 and July 29 debriefings was only $484,020, even though it was never told a second time that its price remained too high.

GAO's Recommendation: Reopen Talks and Re-Award

GAO recommended that the VA "reopen discussions and allow for the submission of revised proposals," then "perform a new evaluation and make a new selection decision consistent with the terms of the solicitation." GAO also recommended that the VA reimburse American Veteran's reasonable costs of filing and pursuing the protest, including attorneys' fees. The protester must submit its certified cost claim to the agency within 60 days of receiving the decision. GAO's recent decisions list shows it posted Nov. 17, 2026.

GAO's recommendations are not binding on agencies. If the VA follows this one, both SDVOSBs get another round of revisions. Veterans Monument does not lose the contract outright, but it will have to compete again against a rival that now has the chance to close the price gap.

What It Means for Contractors

The decision shows that a strong price lead does not protect an award built on uneven discussions. Contracting officers who reopen talks with one offeror, even for what looks like a narrow follow-up, should consider whether the other offerors in the competition have unresolved issues that deserve the same chance to be addressed. Once GAO finds unequal treatment, it gives the protester the benefit of the doubt on prejudice, and a large price gap will not save the award.

The two denied grounds carry their own lessons. A solicitation that says an award may go to the lowest-priced technically acceptable proposal in a tier will be read by its plain language, and GAO will not read in a tradeoff the RFP did not promise. Quality control plan arguments need a clear solicitation requirement behind them, because GAO will not read in staffing detail that the RFP did not demand.

Because the corrective action is limited to reopening discussions with the existing competitors, the practical effect falls mainly on the two SDVOSB finalists, which both priced a five-year IDIQ in the $43 million to $47 million range.

Sources