The Senate's top defense lawmaker has put the White House on notice that Congress will not quietly go along with ripping electromagnetic catapults out of the Navy's newest aircraft carriers. At acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao's confirmation hearing on Nov. 17, Senate Armed Services Committee Chairman Sen. Roger Wicker, R-Miss., told the nominee directly that the idea is dead on arrival, Breaking Defense reported. The exchange pits the committee chairman against a National Security Presidential Memorandum President Trump signed in August, which ordered the Navy to equip Ford-class carriers with steam-powered catapults and hydraulic aircraft elevators like those on the older Nimitz class.

“Secretary Cao, returning to steam is a non-starter, and everybody needs to understand that,” Wicker said during the hearing, according to Breaking Defense. Inside Defense noted that the statement came after Republicans had largely remained silent on the initiative, which makes the chairman's remark a notable break from the president's push.

What Trump's August Carrier Memo Orders

The Ford class was designed around the Electromagnetic Aircraft Launch System, or EMALS, which uses electromagnetic energy rather than steam to launch aircraft from the flight deck. Trump's August memorandum directed the Navy to swap in traditional steam catapults and hydraulic elevators instead. According to Breaking Defense, the directive would apply to ships such as the Doris Miller, now under construction at HII's Newport News Shipbuilding.

The memo frames the change as a cost-control measure. Trump argued that overly complex ship designs and repeated changes have contributed to shipbuilding cost increases, delays and cancellations, and he called on the Navy to prioritize “proven, reliable, and affordable technologies and ship designs.”

The push is not new. Inside Defense described replacing EMALS with the steam launchers used on Nimitz-class carriers as “a longtime focus for Trump, dating back to his first presidential term.” Breaking Defense noted that Trump indicated last year he would direct the Navy to return to steam before he formalized the order in August.

Has the Navy Already Planned the EMALS Replacement?

It has drafted one. According to Inside Defense, “The Navy has completed a plan on the measures required to replace EMALS, as well as the current weapons elevators.” A Navy official told the outlet in October that the plan had gone to the White House Office of Management and Budget for submission to the president and was under review.

That means the conversion is further along than a talking point. A finished plan sitting at OMB gives the administration a ready document to act on, and it gives the Armed Services Committee a concrete target if members decide to use the authorization or appropriations process to block or condition the work.

Kaine Cites Sailors Who Fly Off the Ford

Wicker was not the only senator to challenge the plan. Before the chairman spoke, Sen. Tim Kaine, D-Va., told Cao he had recently visited USS Gerald R. Ford and spoken with sailors who were “very complimentary” of EMALS, Breaking Defense reported. Inside Defense said Kaine spoke with sailors on the flight deck.

“The EMALS system works very well,” Kaine said, according to Inside Defense. He warned that retrofitting existing carriers or changing the design to go back to steam would bring higher costs with “diminished capacity.”

Advertisement

Kaine also urged Cao not to treat the presidential directive as the end of the discussion. “And so, just because the president directed it, I do hope you’ll consider the experience of those who’ve been operating these launches on the Ford in deciding before you decide to go down a path that will be more expensive and also less capable,” he said, as quoted by Breaking Defense.

Breaking Defense reported that both Republican and Democratic lawmakers have pushed back on the plans, and that critics argue the switch would add cost and complexity while reverting to older technology on a carrier class built around EMALS.

Cao Points to Weapons Elevators, Not Just Catapults

Cao did not reject the president's direction. Asked whether the Navy should return to steam catapults, he said EMALS and the electromagnetic elevators outfitted on the Ford are contributing to carrier delays, according to Breaking Defense. Inside Defense reported that Cao said maintaining an 11-carrier presence worldwide is challenging because of delays with EMALS and the elevators.

Advertisement

Defense Daily, which described the session as a contentious confirmation hearing, reported that Cao pointed to problems with the new Advanced Weapons Elevators. That framing shifts part of the argument away from the catapults themselves and toward the broader set of electromagnetic systems that have slowed Ford-class construction.

Inside Defense noted that the electromagnetic elevators have contributed to construction delays, including on the John F. Kennedy (CVN-79). But it also reported that Hudson Institute defense expert Bryan Clark told the outlet in August that redesigning would likely do more harm than good when it comes to speeding up production.

Cao has led the Navy in an acting capacity since April, when former Navy Secretary John Phelan was ousted and Cao, then the undersecretary, assumed the role. Trump announced in September that he would nominate Cao for the permanent job. The catapult exchange was one of several tense moments at the hearing, which also covered the aircraft carrier Abraham Lincoln's extended deployment.

What It Means for Contractors

The catapult fight lands directly on the carrier industrial base. Newport News Shipbuilding is building the Doris Miller, a ship the memo would cover, and any design change midstream would ripple into engineering work, supplier orders and schedules at the yard. Trump's own memo blames repeated design changes for cost growth and delays, and that is the same risk Kaine raised in arguing against a switch back to steam.

For suppliers of launch, recovery and elevator systems, the next signals to watch are procedural. The Navy's completed replacement plan is under review at OMB, and its contents and any cost figures have not been made public. If the administration moves forward, funding would have to flow through budget requests and congressional authorizations, where Wicker chairs the committee that writes the Senate's version of the defense policy bill.

Contractors with work on Ford-class carriers should track three things: whether OMB releases or acts on the Navy plan, whether the Senate confirms Cao and how he handles the directive once confirmed, and whether Armed Services Committee members write language into defense legislation that restricts spending on a steam conversion. Wicker's “non-starter” remark suggests that last option is now a live possibility, not a hypothetical.

Sources