Protests
GAO and Court of Federal Claims bid protest decisions, and what they mean for bidders.
-
Protests
GAO Denies Mustang Survival Protest of Navy Submarine Escape Suit Award, Upholds LPTA Price Reasonableness Finding
GAO denied Mustang Survival's protest of a Navy SESSPE suit award to RFD Beaufort, ruling that LPTA procurements do not require price realism analysis and that the contracting officer reasonably evaluated RFD Beaufort's unit price — approximately 20 percent below the prior contract price — and SPRS past-performance data.
-
Protests
GAO Sustains Owl International Re-Protest of $214M Navy ESSM Award Over Proposal-Revision Scope
GAO has again sustained a protest by Owl International over a roughly $214 million Navy ESSM contract awarded to PCCI, finding the Navy improperly limited final proposal revisions to price only after amending the solicitation to remove FAR 52.222-46.
-
Protests
Court of Federal Claims Tosses CSI Aviation Protest of $915M ICE Deportation-Flight Award to Salus, Citing Lack of Standing
The U.S. Court of Federal Claims dismissed CSI Aviation's protest of a $915M ICE deportation-flight contract awarded to Salus Worldwide, holding CSI lacked standing because it never showed it could perform the work. The award stands despite a compressed, non-competitive procurement.
-
Protests
GAO Dismisses Metro East's Protest of CDC Sole-Source Guard-Services Extension as Untimely — Clock Started at the SAM.gov Posting
GAO dismissed Metro East Joint Venture's protest (B-424392) of a CDC sole-source guard-services extension to incumbent Chenega as untimely. The 10-day clock began with the January 27 SAM.gov justification posting, not the March 25 option exercise, making the April 6 filing over two months late.
-
Protests
GAO Sustains N&S Property Services Protest After ICE's Corrective-Action Reevaluation Again Picked a Higher-Priced Awardee
GAO sustained N&S Property Services' protest of ICE's 8(a) O&M award at Fort Benning after corrective action. The reevaluation applied unstated criteria, added undocumented 'raises confidence' findings for higher-priced KCorp, and tainted the best-value tradeoff, establishing prejudice.
-
Protests
CICA Stay Override Challenges: Federal Circuit Clarifies the Standard but Practical Barriers Remain High
Procurement attorneys say the Federal Circuit's recent ruling clarifying the legal standard for challenging CICA stay overrides has made the law more predictable — but has not made winning any easier, as agencies retain strong deference in override decisions and the declaratory judgment route remains costly and slow.
-
Advertisement
-
Protests
GAO Issues Guidance on Stay Override Challenges and Declaratory Judgment in Bid Protests
The Government Accountability Office clarified agency obligations when overriding automatic bid-protest stays under CICA, and addressed how protestors may seek declaratory judgment in federal court when overrides occur.
-
Protests
NDAA Section 875 Protest Penalties Take Effect in June — What Incumbents Need to Know
Starting in June 2026, contracting officers may withhold up to five percent of payments from incumbents whose GAO protests are found frivolous under NDAA Section 875. The Federal Circuit has also clarified the proper legal vehicle for challenging agency override of automatic protest stays.
-
Protests
Protecting Protest Rights When a Procurement Scandal Is Unfolding: The Diligent Pursuit Obligation
A series of recent GAO decisions establishes that contractors who suspect procurement misconduct cannot preserve their protest rights by passively monitoring events — they must file within the standard timeliness window from the point they knew or should have known of the alleged violation.
-
Protests
GAO Rejects Protest Fishing Expedition, Confirms Protesters Must Plead With Evidence
In Warfighter Focused Logistics, B-423546, GAO dismissed a protest challenging a logistics award, holding that protesters must support their allegations with credible evidence — not mere speculation — before GAO will compel an agency to produce its evaluation record for examination.
-
Protests
Federal Circuit Rules Contractors Need Only Show 'Arbitrary and Capricious' Standard to Challenge CICA Stay Overrides
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ruled in Life Science Logistics v. United States, No. 24-1522, that challengers to CICA automatic stay overrides need only satisfy the arbitrary-and-capricious standard — not the traditional four-factor injunctive relief test — significantly lowering the bar for contractors seeking to reinstate protest stays.
-
Protests
GAO Dismisses Entire Protest After Contractor Files Comments Minutes Past the 5:30 PM Deadline
GAO dismissed Think Tank, Inc.'s entire protest against the Department of Commerce without reaching the merits after the protester's counsel uploaded comments minutes after the 5:30 PM filing deadline due to a filename upload error and subsequent password issue — reaffirming that GAO's filing deadlines are absolute.